SOUTH BEND, Ind. (AP) Notre Dame coach Brian Kelly fell on his sword after his eighth-ranked Fighting Irish struggled offensively against Ball State in what many assumed would be a tuneup game.

''I obviously didn't do a good enough job getting them up to play at the level they need to play,'' Kelly said. ''Ball State did a great job coming into this game and doing what it needed to do. Their preparation was great, their coaching was better.''

On the scoreboard, it was a 24-16 victory for Notre Dame. But it wasn't easy, and it wasn't pretty.

The Irish (2-0), coming off an emotional 24-17 victory over Michigan, looked lackluster against the Mid-American Conference foe whose campus in Muncie is a 2 1/2-hour drive away. The Cardinals (1-1) also played nothing like the 34 1/2-point underdogs they were labeled in the schools' first meeting in football.

Junior strong safety Jalen Elliott picked off Ball State quarterback Riley Neal twice - the first interceptions by a Notre Dame safety in the last 14 games - and the Irish turned them into a pair of rushing touchdowns of 31 and 1 yards by junior Tony Jones Jr. It gave the Irish a 21-6 lead in the third quarter, but Ball State wasn't done.

''Hats off to Ball State,'' Notre Dame linebacker Drue Tranquill said after making nine stops and securing the victory by recovering an onside kick with 1:30 remaining. ''They came here and competed.''

Notre Dame outgained Ball State 414-349 but the Cardinals ran off 97 plays to Notre Dame's 72 and controlled the clock for 8:44 more than the Irish.

''There are no moral victories,'' Ball State coach Mike Neu said. ''We had our chance. Our guys were ready to compete. Whatever we lacked in size, we were going to go compete, go toe-to-toe. We embraced the David vs. Goliath comparison.''

Following a 46-yard field goal by Justin Yoon that gave the Irish a 24-6 lead going into the fourth quarter, Nolan Givan caught a 10-yard scoring pass from Neal, who threw for 180 yards but completed just 23 of 50 passes. A 49-yard field goal by Ball State's Morgan Hagee, his third of the game, closed out the scoring.

''We have to come together,'' Elliott said. ''Coach Kelly said it best. We play nameless and faceless opponents week to week. Everyone's going to bring their best game so we have to respect our opponents to the fullest.''

Junior James Gilbert rushed for 72 yards for Ball State, which outgained Notre Dame on the ground, 169-117. Sophomore Jafar Armstrong led the Irish with 66 yards, including a 42-yard scamper up the middle in the first quarter that he followed with a 1-yard scoring run two plays later. Jones finished with 61 yards.

The Cardinals' 3-4 defense frustrated senior Irish quarterback Brandon Wimbush, who threw for 297 yards but finished with minus 7 yards rushing as Ball State registered four sacks and picked off three of his passes.

''I think we lacked attention to detail and focus, especially in the second half,'' Wimbush said.

His coach wouldn't put the blame for Notre Dame's offensive ineffectiveness on Wimbush's shoulders.

''Brandon wasn't the reason we were ineffective offensively,'' Kelly said. ''You never want your quarterback to throw three interceptions. We're looking at it as we're anxious to go back to work because we're seeing some things we like.''


Notre Dame center Sam Mustipher was not pleased with the offensive line performance but gave credit to Ball State, which finished with 10 tackles for loss. Linebackers Jaylin Thomas and Jacob White and strong safety had nine tackles each for the Cardinals.

''We didn't execute well,'' Mustipher said. ''I don't even know what grade I would give. They were physical, they were moving, blitzing us, pressuring us. They played well.''


Senior middle linebacker Te'von Coney had another big game for Notre Dame, making a team-high 14 tackles, 10 of them solo. He also had Notre Dame's one sack of Neal among his team-high three tackles for loss. Junior cornerback Julian Love, who set a school record with 20 passes broken up last season, finished with four.


Ball State: The Cardinals, who have just nine seniors on the roster, showed that they could be a factor in the MAC race after injuries to Neal and Gilbert last year factored into a nine-game losing streak.

Notre Dame: After receiving the game ball following last week's victory, Wimbush couldn't get things going with his feet as the Cardinals closed his running lanes. His longest gain rushing was 9 yards. But the three interceptions were disappointing.

''Three picks,'' Wimbush said. ''I don't give myself an A, a B ... probably a D, a D-plus. You can't throw three interceptions.''


Notre Dame: The Irish, who rose from No. 12 to No. 8 after the win over Michigan, could lose some ground but should remain in the top 10.


Ball State: The Cardinals visit Indiana on Saturday.

Notre Dame: The Irish host Vanderbilt in their third straight home game.


More AP college football: and

Copyright 2018 by AP. Any commercial use or distribution without the express written consent of AP is strictly prohibited.