Forgot Log-in ID / Password? | Help Not a member, Register Now!
You have received an exclusive opportunity to preview the new CBSSports.com.  Explore the site and let us know what you think.
  New York Giants logo

Register to Customize or Login

New York Giants
Location: East Rutherford, N.J. | Stadium: Giants Stadium (80,242) | President/CEO: John K. Mara, Esq. | GM: Jerry Reese
Coach: Tom Coughlin | League Championships: 4 | Super Bowls: 3
Team HomeScheduleStatsRosterDepth ChartTransactionsTeam ReportPhotosHistoryListen to 660 The FanMessage Board
 

Week 7 Judgements: Cardinals fly right away from their coop

1. Once again, Arizona is the team to beat in the NFC West, and not because Kurt Warner is throwing for a zillion yards. Nope, this time it's because the Cards are doing what they did not a year ago -- winning on the road. They're 3-0 there, including two in the Eastern Time Zone.

2. Great, now the league is serious about putting a team in London. Anybody think it might be a good idea first to get serious about putting a team in L.A.?

3. San Francisco coach Mike Singletary said he will do "what's best for the team" with his starting quarterback. OK, then, start Alex Smith. You just added the franchise wide receiver. So give him a quarterback who can get him the ball.

Week 7 Judgements: Cardinals fly right away from their coop - NFL - CBSSports.com Football

4. The difference with New England the past month is not Tom Brady. It's Wes Welker. Since returning from a knee injury, Welker has 34 catches in four games -- including 10 in each of the past two starts. Oh, yeah, he also has four TDs since coming back. Welker is Brady's security blanket, and without him Brady and the Patriots offense aren't the same.

5. The next two games will tell us how far Cincinnati goes, with the Bengals facing Baltimore at home and Pittsburgh in Pittsburgh. Let's say they lose both. They still look good as a wild card, and here's why: After Pittsburgh they draw, in order, Oakland, Cleveland and Detroit: opponents with a combined record of 4-16. At worst, they're 8-4 after 12 games.

6. The NFL loves to talk about how close some of its games have been, and I understand. But now it's time to talk about Blowout Sunday. There were six games where 28 or more points decided the outcome, and that's a testament to the disparity in this league. When the haves (Indianapolis, New England, Green Bay) meet the have-nots (St. Louis, Tampa Bay, Cleveland) it's ugly.

7. It was a good week for Tom Cable. First, he wasn't charged by the Napa district attorney's office. Then he had the guts (smarts?) to bench JaMarcus Russell.

8. Make that two wrecks in one week for Cleveland's Eric Wright.

9. Now I know why Cincinnati's Cedric Benson reportedly didn't want to be drafted by the Bears. I have never, ever, ever, seen a more disgraceful performance by a Chicago defense that didn't include Milton Bradley.

10. Let's hear it for Josh Cribbs. Given the chance to blame Cleveland's latest blowout on the flu that swept through the team, Cribbs took the high road and passed. "You can't make excuses," he said. "We played some bad football." That's a big 10-4, Josh. Bad enough the Browns didn't score an offensive touchdown. Browns fans are used to that by now. But no sacks of Aaron Rodgers? This is a guy who was dumped a league-record 25 times entering the game, for crying out loud. And the Browns can't put a hand on him? Remind me why it was such a good idea to hire Eric Mangini.

11. When you're talking accurate quarterbacks, you start the conversation with Peyton Manning. Rewind the videotape of his touchdown pass to Dallas Clark, and you'll know why.

12. Shame on Todd Haley. I know his team won only once, but that's no excuse to go brain dead on us. How else do you explain Haley's decision to go for it on fourth-and-1 at his own 41 late in the first quarter? The Chiefs were down by only seven. But go he did, calling a quarterback sneak, and it blew up on him. Haley should fire his play caller. Oh, wait a minute, he did.

13. Now, more than ever, the Carolina Panthers need to wake up to the reality of Jake Delhomme. He no longer gets you to the next level, and, yes, those 13 interceptions convinced me. Add them to last year's finale, and Delhomme has 18 interceptions in his past seven starts. Read the tea leaves, Carolina: It's time to draft your next quarterback.

14. Miami has itself to blame for blowing a 24-3 lead, but you can't blame the Dolphins if they're irked with officials. They spotted New Orleans a score, and follow me here. On the last play of the first half, Marques Colston makes a catch and stretches for the end zone ... with a touchdown called. Only it wasn't a touchdown, and because the Saints were out of timeouts, that would have been the half. But now there's a replay review, the clock stops and the Saints get one more snap. Touchdown. If the right call had been made, they would've been in the locker room, but, hey, that's no excuse for blowing a 21-point lead.

15. LaDainian Tomlinson isn't LaDainian Tomlinson anymore, and those eight carries inside the Chiefs 5 are the proof. He didn't score once. But I'd like to see what would happen if there were actually a hole to run through. Man, the Chargers offensive line is brutal.

Sez them ... or Rapid Reporters' Rewind

From Eric Gilmore in Oakland ... There is no quarterback controversy in Oakland. After Sunday's 38-0 loss, Tom Cable said JaMarcus Russell would remain his quarterback. Still, by benching Russell on Sunday, he sent a message that the guy isn't above sitting down. "For the first time," Cable said, "I thought he was really out of sorts early in the game."

From Josh Katzowitz in Cincinnati ... You can't blame former Chicago running back Cedric Benson for staring down his ex-teammates as the clock wound down. "That was an emotional moment," he said. "A small part of me just couldn't resist going over there and showing emotion."

From Jim McCurdy in Houston ... One more fumble makes it four for the season for Houston's Steve Slaton.

From Carter Gaddis in London ... If there were any doubts about how closely Tampa Bay coach Raheem Morris and GM Mark Domenik are linked, they ended when Morris consulted Domenik on the wisdom of inserting Freeman in Sunday's game. The team has tried to protect the 21-year-old rookie, but an 0-7 record entering the bye gives them an ideal opportunity to turn the offense over to him.

Five things I like

1. Sports Illustrated: The Football Book Expanded Edition. It's not a good coffee table book. It's a magnificent one. My all-time favorite is The Pros: A Documentary of Professional Football in America, with scores of illustrations and black-and-white photos by Robert Riger. I bought it as a kid and cherished it as I grew older. Anyone who grew up a Unitas fan would. But there are Unitas photos here, too, as well as plenty of others of players past and present -- with some of the best color photos I've seen anywhere, which is what you would expect from Sports Illustrated. If you follow pro football, you'll want this book.

The Bucs do a smart thing by letting QB Josh Freeman play. (US Presswire)  
The Bucs do a smart thing by letting QB Josh Freeman play. (US Presswire)  
2. Adrian Peterson's demolition of defensive back William Gay on his 29-yard catch-and-run on the Vikings' next-to-last drive. Peterson didn't try to elude Gay; he ran through him, flattening the poor guy.

3. Tampa Bay finally turning to Josh Freeman. It's about time, guys. Someone must have had a conviction about him to make him a first-round draft pick, and I would hope it's coach Raheem Morris. So play him and play him now. What do you have to lose?

4. The Dallas pass rush. Before Sunday, Matt Ryan had been sacked twice -- both in the Falcons' first game. That means he went the next four without getting dumped. So what happens against the Cowboys? He gets sacked four times, or twice his season total, including two by DeMarcus Ware.

5. Steven Jackson's effort. Don't fault the Rams running back for that 0-7 start. Granted, he doesn't have a touchdown, but he does have three 100-yard games and gains 4.4 yards per carry. Any idea how difficult that is when you're the center of every opponent's attention?

Five things I don't

1. The Vikings throwing on second and third downs after driving to the Pittsburgh 1 late in the third period. When you have Adrian Peterson and need 1 yard, you don't throw to the end zone. Not only did the Vikings do it twice, when they failed, they settled for a field goal. Crazy.

2. The Yankees and Giants playing at the same time. The only guy in the greater New York area who was grateful was Tom Coughlin. The Yankees took the heat off him and his listless club for the second successive weekend.

3. Mark Sanchez eating a hot dog during the fourth quarter of the Jets' shredding of Oakland. Sanchez apologized for it later, but, c'mon, Mark, you must be smarter than that. It's one thing for Barry Switzer to do it at the Pro Bowl; it's another for someone to try it during a regular-season game ... and a rookie, no less. Headline writers don't need more material than they already have, Mark.

4. Khalif Barnes against Calvin Pace. It's the worst mismatch since Billy Joel and Christie Brinkley. Pace started the game by sacking JaMarcus Russell and forcing a fumble; then separated Russell's replacement, Bruce Gradkowski, from the ball on the first series of the second half. He finished with seven tackles, three sacks and two forced fumbles.

5. Any regular-season game in England. It's a competitive disadvantage to the home team. Of course, any game anywhere is a competitive disadvantage for the Tampa Bay Bucs.

Just asking but ...

 Will the real San Diego Chargers please stand up?
 What next for JaMarcus Russell?
 How did Kevin Boss hold on after that Antrel Rolle head shot?
 Does Trent Edwards ever get his job back?
 Is Miles Austin for real?

Significant numbers

 0 -- Rushing touchdowns for Kansas City this season
 2 -- Percy Harvin touchdown returns this season
 5 -- Michael Crabtree touches
 17 -- New Orleans takeaways, five under last season's total
 634 -- Yards rushing by the New York Jets the past two games
 1,036 -- New England yards the past two games
 2-7 -- Chicago's road record the past nine games
 3-0 -- Dallas after byes under Wade Phillips
 82-7 -- New York's teams vs. Oakland

My top five

1. Indianapolis
2. New Orleans
3. Denver
4. Pittsburgh
5. Minnesota

My bottom five

32. St. Louis
31. Tampa Bay
30. Cleveland
29. Tennessee
28. Detroit

Next weekend's three best games

New York Giants at Philadelphia ... Best Philly show since Todd, the Hooters and Hall and Oates played the Spectrum.
Minnesota at Green Bay ... Homecoming week for Brett Favre.
Denver at Baltimore ... The Big D is in Denver, not Charm City.

 
 

Giants Headlines
Talk Back
Reputation:85
Level:All-Star
Since:Mar 26, 2009

October 26, 2009 11:21 am
Wouldn't you say the Bengals are now a Top 5 team?
Reputation:98
Level:Superstar
Since:Dec 10, 2006

October 26, 2009 10:40 am
There were six games where 28 or more points decided the outcome, and that's a testament to the disparity in this league. This occurence was even more notable than just the final point totals.  Of these six games, four of the losing teams lost by at least four TDs while playing on their home field.  These teams - the ...(more)
Reputation:95
Level:Superstar
Since:Apr 28, 2008

October 26, 2009 3:45 am
So the Chargers beat a lame Kansas City team and people get excited? The real Chargers wont stand up because this is what they do best, they are the most inconsistent team in the history in the NFL and that is what makes them so frustrating to watch. I dont care what happens, Norv has to go asap. Im not for one second believing that everythi ...(more)
Reputation:79
Level:Pro
Since:Nov 3, 2008

October 27, 2009 1:49 am
After watching the Carolina Panthers put on a passable remake of a Three Stooges movie this weekend, I can't take them seriously anymore.
This was a slapstick comedy with more than it's share of bumbling adventures and starring as Moe, of course, was Jake Delhome. This is a guy who every time he touched the ball, there w
...(more)
Reputation:95
Level:Superstar
Since:Apr 28, 2008

October 26, 2009 3:49 am
So the Chargers beat a lame Kansas City team and people get excited? The real Chargers wont stand up because this is what they do best, they are the most inconsistent team in the history in the NFL and that is what makes them so frustrating to watch. I dont care what happens, Norv has to go asap. Im not for one second believing that ev ...(more)
Reputation:98
Level:Superstar
Since:Sep 2, 2008

October 26, 2009 12:25 pm
On "judgment 14" Judge blames the officials for stopping the clock to review the Colston play. Actually, the clock was going to start upon placement of the ball and therefore the Saints were going to attempt a FG. Sporano then inexplicably called a timeout -- quite possibly the dumbest timeout in the history of the game of football ...(more)
Reputation:98
Level:Superstar
Since:Dec 1, 2006

October 26, 2009 10:00 am
Miami has itself to blame for blowing a 24-3 lead, but you can't blame the Dolphins if they're irked with officials. They spotted New Orleans a score, and follow me here. On the last play of the first half, ...(more)
Reputation:97
Level:Superstar
Since:Nov 22, 2007

October 26, 2009 8:58 am
Seriously, how a team plays in a particular time zone?  This is about the 15th time in the last year or so I have read something about how the Cardinals play in the eastern time zone. 

Without going into detailed human biology, let's just acknowledge for once and for all that NFL players can adjust normally to a m
...(more)
Reputation:81
Level:All-Star
Since:Sep 14, 2009

October 26, 2009 10:31 am

Saints vs Miami. The initial call was a touchdown. The clock STOPS Clark. Booth review time.  The clock does not run while they review it. It starts when they spot the ball. The refs got it halfway right because if you WATCH the replay Colston actually fumbled and recovered in the end zone. It was Sporano who called time out and allo ...(more)

Reputation:95
Level:Superstar
Since:Apr 28, 2008

October 26, 2009 3:43 am
So the Chargers beat a lame Kansas City team and people get excited? The real Chargers wont stand up because this is what they do best, they are the most inconsistent team in the history in the NFL and that is what makes them so frustrating to watch. I dont care what happens, Norv has to go asap. Im not for one second believing that everythi ...(more)
Reputation:94
Level:All-Star
Since:Dec 11, 2007

October 26, 2009 3:36 pm
Haha the Cowboys are ya bums. The Giants losing to the Cardinals???? The Cowboys beating the Falcons!!! Well thats the test and Dallas aced it.
Reputation:96
Level:Superstar
Since:Feb 5, 2007

October 26, 2009 4:11 pm
Could the Giants lose and be overshadowed a 3rd time by the yankees. Maybe. They could theoretically end the series that day. A sweep one way or the other will definately make most forget all about whatever happened in the NFL. That being said go Phillies and Eagles.
Reputation:98
Level:Superstar
Since:Aug 21, 2006

October 26, 2009 3:34 am
Starting Alex Smith is Mike Singletary's proper course of action if he wants to do what's best for the Cardinals, not the 49ers. As for the ...(more)
Reputation:92
Level:All-Star
Since:May 16, 2007

October 26, 2009 12:02 pm
Yeah Welker has done a fantastic job against the vaunted Tampa and Oakland defenses.  I fully admit he helps Brady but pointing out he has put up some yards in blowouts of terrible teams is irrelevant.

Reputation:94
Level:All-Star
Since:Sep 6, 2007

October 26, 2009 10:08 am
can someone explain to me how sanchez eating a hot dog during a game is a big deal? i didnt see the Jets game so im assuming people are taking it as he was disrespecting the other team? but why? the guy was hungry, the game was a blowout & he was on the sidelines?! its not like he was chowing down while trying to call plays in the ...(more)
 
 
 
 
Clark Judge
Recent Columns
 
Headlines
 
 
 
CBS Sports Store