Forgot Log-in ID / Password? | Help Not a member, Register Now!
You have received an exclusive opportunity to preview the new CBSSports.com.  Explore the site and let us know what you think.
 

Power Rankings: You win, McDaniels; apologies to you

Updated Oct. 20

It all seems so hard to believe. A coaching star is fired, replaced by a fresh-faced kid whose claim to fame is calling plays for one of the era's great quarterbacks. The kid then jettisons the young franchise quarterback he inherits, brings in "his" guy to play the position, and then fist-pumps his way to a 6-0 start doing things exactly the way he said he would do them.

Power Rankings: You win, McDaniels; apologies to you - NFL - CBSSports.com Football

Who was I to doubt Josh McDaniels?

I'm done being a Denver Broncos skeptic. For weeks, I kept saying they weren't as good as their record. Dallas, I said, would beat them. They didn't. New England surely would. Nope. But, wait, San Diego had to have Monday's game if the Chargers were to have any real chance of winning the AFC West. Plus, they were coming off a bye, a rested, desperate team.

The final was Denver 34, San Diego 23. So much for that angle.

Division race: Over.

My doubts about the Broncos: Over.

The Broncos and McDaniels are proving to many people, me included, that we have no idea what to expect each and every NFL season. Anybody outside the Rocky Mountain region not named McDaniels who thought this would be a playoff team is lying worse than that balloon fool.

I have been a champion McDaniels ripper. Maybe even the gold-medal winner.

He traded away Jay Cutler. I ripped him.

He smugly answered questions at the league meetings about his decision to consider the move -- before it was made. I ripped him.

Let's see. I ripped him for mimicking Bill Belichick -- hoodie and whistle twirling included -- and I ripped him for his apparent disdain for the media, including not making time for his local beat guys at the combine, not even 15 minutes.

At 6-0, none of that matters now. McDaniels could push cameramen around now, just like Bill, and it wouldn't matter. He can browbeat the media, just like Bill, and it wouldn't bother anybody. He can put up all those cliché signs that Bill uses -- "Do Your Job" is a favorite -- and nobody blinks an eye. If he wanted to send Brandon Marshall to Siberia, it wouldn't matter.

That's what winning can do. It makes McDaniels look smarter than everybody else, certainly smarter than me, and leaves those of us who questioned him wondering why we ever did.

The Broncos face a tough schedule the next month or so. They play at Baltimore, home against Pittsburgh, at Washington (OK, not so tough), home against San Diego and then home against the New York Giants on Thanksgiving.

I would say those five games will get the best of the Broncos. But the way they're going, I won't dare.

The Broncos head to their bye week at 6-0, which has them in the fourth spot in our Power Rankings. It's hard to believe they are 6-0 and the Tennessee Titans are 0-6. And who could have imagined Kyle Orton would be an MVP candidate?

That's the beauty of the NFL.

It's also what makes it so maddening to try to figure out.

Power Rankings
CurrentTeamPrevious
Saints1Saints · Trends4
What is hidden about the Saints is that there are a lot of good, young players on their roster. I can't imagine them taking a big step back.
Colts2Colts · Trends1
Let's not forget they get Anthony Gonzalez back next year, which will make the offense better. They are the team to beat in the AFC again.
Vikings3Vikings · Trends5
After blowing a chance to win the NFC title game in regulation, it must have killed the Vikings to see the Saints win the Super Bowl. Now Minnesota has to play the waiting game with Brett Favre.
Chargers4Chargers · Trends2
They have a lot of contracts that come up, and they will have to make some tough decisions. There is still a lot of talent on this team, but they have to get over the hump at some point. Losing to the Jets was a big upset.
Cowboys5Cowboys · Trends3
Wade Phillips comes back for another year, and he has to get this team past the first round of the playoffs again. Tony Romo is in the same situation.
Eagles6Eagles · Trends6
Can we stop the Donovan McNabb trade talk? He will be back, and he should be back. Will Brian Westbrook?
Jets7Jets · Trends11
The next step will be letting Mark Sanchez do more. They have to throw it better in 2010. And they will.
Packers8Packers · Trends7
Aaron Rodgers showed he's a star in the making this season. That will make Green Bay a Super threat in 2010.
Bengals9Bengals · Trends8
They made big strides to win the division, but they have to improve the passing game. That means getting speed help outside.
Ravens10Ravens · Trends12
It's time for Joe Flacco and that passing game to take a big step forward. You have to get big chunks of yardage to win in this league.
Patriots11Patriots · Trends10
Tom Brady will be a year removed from his knee injury, which means he will be better. The key for the Patriots will be improving their pass rush.
Cardinals12Cardinals · Trends9
Matt Leinart takes over for the retired Kurt Warner. There are a lot of questions about the former Heisman winner, but the Cardinals staff believes in him. Do his teammates?
Broncos13Broncos · Trends13
What do they do with Brandon Marshall? Is he back? Is he traded? They need him, that's for sure.
Steelers14Steelers · Trends14
The concerns with this team are on both lines. They have to play better there. Isn't that the Steelers way?
Texans15Texans · Trends15
They had a winning season, but it's time to make the playoffs. They do have an explosive passing game, which gives them a good chance.
Falcons16Falcons · Trends16
They played the Saints tough twice with a lot of injuries. That has to give them hope heading into next season. They have to work on fixing that defense.
Giants17Giants · Trends20
There is some talk that Tom Coughlin could be in trouble if he doesn't win next season. I don't buy it. But they do have to improve the defense.
Titans18Titans · Trends17
Vince Young played well when he took over. Now he has to show he can do it again.
Dolphins19Dolphins · Trends18
I think this is a team to watch in 2010. Chad Henne will give the Dolphins a better chance to get to a Super Bowl. He does need a receiver.
49ers2049ers · Trends19
The Niners have talent, but they have to throw it better to be a playoff team. I think Alex Smith just might be the answer. The offensive line needs fixing.
Jaguars21Jaguars · Trends21
Jack Del Rio got another year, which some question. Does his quarterback get the same?
Panthers22Panthers · Trends22
They have to decide who plays quarterback. Is it Matt Moore or Jake Delhomme? It should be Moore. What to do with Julius Peppers?
Redskins23Redskins · Trends23
Mike Shanahan has to decide if Jason Campbell is his quarterback of choice. I bet he decides that he is. Hiring Jim Haslett was a good move for the defense.
Bears24Bears · Trends24
Lovie Smith has one year to show that he can turn this team around. Hiring Mike Martz as offensive coordinator is a great move.
Seahawks25Seahawks · Trends25
Pete Carroll has a long way to go to turn this team around. First decision is if Matt Hasselbeck is the right guy at quarterback.
Bills26Bills · Trends26
Is Chan Gailey the right choice? Let's put it this way: His hiring was a surprise. He does know offense.
Chiefs27Chiefs · Trends28
You can bet the first priority is trying to improve that offensive line. Matt Cassel took a beating.
Browns28Browns · Trends27
Eric Mangini gets another year, and he probably earned it late. Can Mike Holmgren turn this team around? He has a lot of work to do.
Buccaneers29Buccaneers · Trends30
Raheem Morris gets another year and his team should be better just because Josh Freeman will be better. Hey, they did beat the Saints late in the season.
Raiders30Raiders · Trends29
Tom Cable is back. Is that a good thing? Who knows? If they don't fix the quarterback position, does it matter?
Lions31Lions · Trends31
It's all about improving the defense. They need pass-rush help in the worst way. They are another year away from competing -- at least.
Rams32Rams · Trends32
They have a huge decision at the top of the draft: Do they take a quarterback or do they solve that by acquiring Michael Vick? We'll see.
 
For more from Pete Prisco, check him out on Twitter: @PriscoCBS
 

Talk Back
Reputation:43
Level:Rookie
Since:Jan 15, 2007

October 26, 2009 9:14 pm
the way to start this conversation its to put the teams that are going to get to the playoffs, make a top 12 list and 2 or 3 teams that might get there.

teams that are not going to make it:

Bills ,
...(more)
Reputation:76
Level:Pro
Since:Apr 9, 2009

October 22, 2009 7:20 am

The Saints to me are too explosive not to have in 1st. They thrashed the G-men without much of a running game at all and their D creates turnovers. DB at QB is surely the leading MVP candidate. They will be a heavy task for anyone all year. Colts are nasty but I still dont know what kind of team they are. ...(more)

Reputation:88
Level:All-Star
Since:Jan 12, 2007

October 22, 2009 9:25 am

What's the matter Pete? Afraid to put the Colts #2 behind the obvious choice at #1 being New Orleans? I really think we need to take away your man card!! You've been having the Giants sitting at #1 and after a total disassembly of said team, you still have to keep a Manning at #1. ...(more)

Reputation:94
Level:All-Star
Since:May 20, 2008

October 22, 2009 12:15 am
Ok here we go again. The Top ten are probably correct just not in the correct order. 1. Has to be the Saints. They just torched one of the best D's in football the Giants couldn't stop Bree's and the this offensive juggernault. 2. ...(more)
Reputation:90
Level:All-Star
Since:Sep 29, 2008

October 20, 2009 10:32 pm
1. (2) Indianapolis - Some may say the Saints should be #1 but I have had the Colts ranked above them all year and I don't feel they have done anything to deserve a demotion.

2. (3) New Orleans - Wow! I definitely thought the Saints could win that game but they did it convi
...(more)
Reputation:84
Level:All-Star
Since:Feb 2, 2009

October 22, 2009 2:15 pm
  1. Saints.  I don't see why they wouldn't be the natural choice for #1.  I'll go further than that.  I think they're far and above whoever is #2.  Unless they have a meltdown soon, I don't see them losing this season.
  2. Patriots.  Can you say upw ...(more)
Reputation:93
Level:All-Star
Since:Jul 6, 2009

October 20, 2009 7:14 pm
Here are the rankings by cumulative grade point average through week 6 from Prisco's weekly grading session.

1. Saints  (3.72)
2. Broncos (3.66)
3. Colts    (3.26
...(more)
Reputation:95
Level:Superstar
Since:Jul 30, 2008

October 21, 2009 3:18 pm
Ok just for the record Pete... I agree 100% Vince Young should be in there.  However, if you are basing this on numbers from last game... I am terribly sorry you didn't watch any of the game, the WR should be thrown under the bus.  Another thing is, they should have changed QB's at the first sign of their downfall, beca ...(more)
Reputation:98
Level:Superstar
Since:May 15, 2007

October 20, 2009 10:14 pm
I have a few thoughts on this weeks power rankings. First off Prisco says,

The Broncos and McDaniels are proving to many people, me included, that we have no idea what to expect each and every NFL season. If you needed the Broncos to prove this to you this year then
...(more)
Reputation:91
Level:All-Star
Since:Dec 2, 2007

October 20, 2009 9:38 pm

1. Colts
Peyton Manning is the best player in the NFL through the first six weeks. His numbers are off the charts. Again. Difference is this year: his team is backing him up with not average but solid play.
2. ...(more)

Reputation:94
Level:All-Star
Since:Sep 9, 2009

October 21, 2009 12:25 pm

First, I am a Ravens fan and some of this may come off as an angry fan but hey thats why we watch right.  This bye week will show a lot about the ravens resillience especially in the secondary.  The Defense for Baltimore has always been a proud unit and with the corners of seasons past, ...(more)

Reputation:96
Level:Superstar
Since:Dec 6, 2007

October 21, 2009 10:19 am

1. Saints - After handling the Giants, who were easily the best team in the NFL, I easily hand the number one spot to the saints until further notice.

2. Broncos - Maybe not the sexiest team, but with wins over t ...(more)

Reputation:95
Level:Superstar
Since:Jul 13, 2009

October 20, 2009 5:09 pm
Here are my thoughts:

1.  Broncos-- Okay Saints\Colts fans, you can get mad at this.  But Denver has a defense that has given up 3 second half points in its last five games.  In December and Janua
...(more)
Reputation:94
Level:All-Star
Since:Sep 11, 2009

October 21, 2009 1:41 pm
*Disclaimer: Power Rankings are pointless and function only to enrage the fans of teams who believe that their team should be #1.

Only comment about the top of the list....Saints are #1.  They are a multi-faceted team with alot of talent and potential.  Kudos to new Orleans...after so many years of disappointment...maybe this is your year!  Maybe if when considering the
...(more)
Reputation:92
Level:All-Star
Since:Dec 31, 2007

October 21, 2009 11:22 am
1. Indianapolis- With Manning at the top of his game, the Colts are a fearsome sight to many opponents. Next week they are facing the Rams. Easy win IMO.

2. Saints- Clicking offensively, the Saints are anot
...(more)
 
 
 
 
Pete Prisco
Recent Columns
 
Headlines
 
 
 
CBS Sports Store
Reebok New Orleans Saints Super Bowl XLIV Champions Locker Room T-Shirt
New Orleans Saints XLIV Super Bowl Champs
Get your Gear Shop Now