Forgot Log-in ID / Password? | Help Not a member, Register Now!
You have received an exclusive opportunity to preview the new CBSSports.com.  Explore the site and let us know what you think.
 

Power Rankings: Optimism is great, but usual suspects in top 10

Updated July 28

Training camp is here, which means optimism is everywhere. Yes, even in places like Detroit and Oakland.

And of course, it means we're waiting to see if that Wrangler guy leaves the tractor to throw footballs again rather than texting with his favorite reporters.

Carson Palmer's return gives Cincy a chance to contend in the AFC North. (Getty Images)  
Carson Palmer's return gives Cincy a chance to contend in the AFC North. (Getty Images)  
July and August in the NFL are all about hopes and wishes and dreams, visions of that big silver trophy dancing in the heads of players and coaches and, yes, you the fans.

There isn't a player or coach in the league who won't tell you his team doesn't have a playoff chance, and they mean it. OK, some coaches know better and they'll lie like Michael Vick to the commissioner, but players truly believe it, even those who play for the Lions.

Why wouldn't they? Every year, we see teams that didn't make the playoffs the previous season come crashing into the postseason party, waving their invitation in the faces of those who were certain they would get one, only to be left waiting at the velvet ropes without one.

Even I'm optimistic at this time of the year, and, if you know me, that's as strange as hearing those rumors about Tony Romo and that Blame It On Rio girl -- or should I say "cougar" now.

Cue the cat noises to irritate Jessica Simpson.

With camps opening, it's time for our first "real" CBSSports.com Power Rankings of 2009. This batch has no looking-back data included. It's all forward thinking, which is why some of the slotting will drive you batty.

Take a look at the No. 13 and No. 17 spots. Those two teams are guaranteed to infuriate. You will cry that the Cincinnati Bengals in the No. 13 spot are way too high and the Minnesota Vikings in the No. 17 spot are way too low.

They're that way for a reason: Quarterback. The Bengals get theirs back in Carson Palmer, and when he's on the field he's a top-five passer. The Vikings don't have a top-15 passer, even if Brett Favre does decide to play.

Poll
Which team should be No. 1?
 
41%
Steelers
 
 
21%
None of these teams
 
 
20%
Patriots
 
 
10%
Eagles
 
 
5%
Colts
 
 
3%
Cardinals
 
Total Votes: 41487

Vikings fans and coaches are pinning their hopes that Favre plays. They think he can back off a defense and let Adrian Peterson run wild. No more eight in the box. Did I miss something last year when Favre couldn't throw the ball down the field for the Jets? Who's he backing off?

The Patriots sit in the top spot because they have the deepest team with the best coach and they get Tom Brady back. That doesn't mean they're the Super pick yet. I will make that choice later in the summer, but you can bet they will get strong consideration.

The top 10 features all the usual suspects, which is why I'm a little nervous. There will be three or four teams that make it to the top 10 before the season ends that aren't there now. It happens every year.

Cincinnati could be one. So could Green Bay. Or Houston. Or Carolina. Or just about anybody.

That's the greatness of the NFL. The college season will be decided by a handful of teams. Pencil me in for Florida vs. Texas right now (have you seen their schedules?). But in the NFL, there are 20 teams that have Super chances, which is why there is so much optimism around the league in July and August.

Heck, I'm even Mr. Sunshine. Maybe that guy who sticks his ass in my face getting his luggage out of the overhead on my first flight of my training camp tour won't annoy me. Maybe that two-hour delay for mechanical reasons won't irritate me. Maybe getting lost driving through farmland to get to Terre Haute, Ind. -- have you played count the silos? -- won't get my blood boiling.

It's July, even a curmudgeon like myself can feel the wave of optimism. Of course, like the hope of some NFL teams, it's bound to fade by September.

Power Rankings
CurrentTeamPrevious
Saints1Saints · Trends4
What is hidden about the Saints is that there are a lot of good, young players on their roster. I can't imagine them taking a big step back.
Colts2Colts · Trends1
Let's not forget they get Anthony Gonzalez back next year, which will make the offense better. They are the team to beat in the AFC again.
Vikings3Vikings · Trends5
After blowing a chance to win the NFC title game in regulation, it must have killed the Vikings to see the Saints win the Super Bowl. Now Minnesota has to play the waiting game with Brett Favre.
Chargers4Chargers · Trends2
They have a lot of contracts that come up, and they will have to make some tough decisions. There is still a lot of talent on this team, but they have to get over the hump at some point. Losing to the Jets was a big upset.
Cowboys5Cowboys · Trends3
Wade Phillips comes back for another year, and he has to get this team past the first round of the playoffs again. Tony Romo is in the same situation.
Eagles6Eagles · Trends6
Can we stop the Donovan McNabb trade talk? He will be back, and he should be back. Will Brian Westbrook?
Jets7Jets · Trends11
The next step will be letting Mark Sanchez do more. They have to throw it better in 2010. And they will.
Packers8Packers · Trends7
Aaron Rodgers showed he's a star in the making this season. That will make Green Bay a Super threat in 2010.
Bengals9Bengals · Trends8
They made big strides to win the division, but they have to improve the passing game. That means getting speed help outside.
Ravens10Ravens · Trends12
It's time for Joe Flacco and that passing game to take a big step forward. You have to get big chunks of yardage to win in this league.
Patriots11Patriots · Trends10
Tom Brady will be a year removed from his knee injury, which means he will be better. The key for the Patriots will be improving their pass rush.
Cardinals12Cardinals · Trends9
Matt Leinart takes over for the retired Kurt Warner. There are a lot of questions about the former Heisman winner, but the Cardinals staff believes in him. Do his teammates?
Broncos13Broncos · Trends13
What do they do with Brandon Marshall? Is he back? Is he traded? They need him, that's for sure.
Steelers14Steelers · Trends14
The concerns with this team are on both lines. They have to play better there. Isn't that the Steelers way?
Texans15Texans · Trends15
They had a winning season, but it's time to make the playoffs. They do have an explosive passing game, which gives them a good chance.
Falcons16Falcons · Trends16
They played the Saints tough twice with a lot of injuries. That has to give them hope heading into next season. They have to work on fixing that defense.
Giants17Giants · Trends20
There is some talk that Tom Coughlin could be in trouble if he doesn't win next season. I don't buy it. But they do have to improve the defense.
Titans18Titans · Trends17
Vince Young played well when he took over. Now he has to show he can do it again.
Dolphins19Dolphins · Trends18
I think this is a team to watch in 2010. Chad Henne will give the Dolphins a better chance to get to a Super Bowl. He does need a receiver.
49ers2049ers · Trends19
The Niners have talent, but they have to throw it better to be a playoff team. I think Alex Smith just might be the answer. The offensive line needs fixing.
Jaguars21Jaguars · Trends21
Jack Del Rio got another year, which some question. Does his quarterback get the same?
Panthers22Panthers · Trends22
They have to decide who plays quarterback. Is it Matt Moore or Jake Delhomme? It should be Moore. What to do with Julius Peppers?
Redskins23Redskins · Trends23
Mike Shanahan has to decide if Jason Campbell is his quarterback of choice. I bet he decides that he is. Hiring Jim Haslett was a good move for the defense.
Bears24Bears · Trends24
Lovie Smith has one year to show that he can turn this team around. Hiring Mike Martz as offensive coordinator is a great move.
Seahawks25Seahawks · Trends25
Pete Carroll has a long way to go to turn this team around. First decision is if Matt Hasselbeck is the right guy at quarterback.
Bills26Bills · Trends26
Is Chan Gailey the right choice? Let's put it this way: His hiring was a surprise. He does know offense.
Chiefs27Chiefs · Trends28
You can bet the first priority is trying to improve that offensive line. Matt Cassel took a beating.
Browns28Browns · Trends27
Eric Mangini gets another year, and he probably earned it late. Can Mike Holmgren turn this team around? He has a lot of work to do.
Buccaneers29Buccaneers · Trends30
Raheem Morris gets another year and his team should be better just because Josh Freeman will be better. Hey, they did beat the Saints late in the season.
Raiders30Raiders · Trends29
Tom Cable is back. Is that a good thing? Who knows? If they don't fix the quarterback position, does it matter?
Lions31Lions · Trends31
It's all about improving the defense. They need pass-rush help in the worst way. They are another year away from competing -- at least.
Rams32Rams · Trends32
They have a huge decision at the top of the draft: Do they take a quarterback or do they solve that by acquiring Michael Vick? We'll see.
 
For more from Pete Prisco, check him out on Twitter: @PriscoCBS
 

Talk Back
Reputation:90
Level:All-Star
Since:Apr 29, 2007

July 28, 2009 2:29 pm
No question the Pats are #1.  They won 11 games with a high school QB at the helm last season.  I feel sorry for the rest of the AFC East.  Its gonna get ugly. Remember all the crying about the Patriots running up the score in 2007? It may be even worse this year. 
 
 
 
 
Pete Prisco
Recent Columns
 
Headlines
 
 
 
CBS Sports Store
Reebok New Orleans Saints Super Bowl XLIV Champions Locker Room T-Shirt
New Orleans Saints XLIV Super Bowl Champs
Get your Gear Shop Now