Forgot Log-in ID / Password? | Help Not a member, Register Now!
You have received an exclusive opportunity to preview the new CBSSports.com.  Explore the site and let us know what you think.
 

Watch your favorite commercials from Super Bowl 2010. Watch now!

 
Prisco Grades: Week 8
 
Pete Prisco By Pete Prisco
CBSSports.com Senior Writer
Tell Pete your opinion!
 
 
CBSSports.com Senior Writer Pete Prisco grades each team's performance every week.
 
 
Week1 · 2 · 3 · 4 · 5 · 6 · 7 · 8 · 9 · 10 · 11 · 12 · 13 · 14 · 15 · 16 · 17
 
PostseasonWild Card · Divisional · Conference Championship · Probowl
 
Prisco's Picks · Prisco's Grades · Expert Picks · Harmon Forecast
 

Twenty-one days is about the time it takes me to gain two or three pounds during fat-ball -- er, football -- season.

Tom Coughlin's defense is struggling to stop the pass. (Getty Images)  
Tom Coughlin's defense is struggling to stop the pass. (Getty Images)  

It's also the amount of time it has taken the New York Giants to go from checking on reservations in Miami for the Super Bowl to checking on reservations for offseason vacations -- in January.

OK, so it might not be that bad. But after the Giants were blown out 40-17 by the Philadelphia Eagles on Sunday, their third consecutive loss, they have to be scrambling to figure out what went wrong.

Two weeks ago, I remember walking into the Superdome for the game against the New Orleans Saints telling some in the press box that the Giants were the best team in the league and coach Tom Coughlin just might win his second Super Bowl.

They were blown out by the Saints, then lost to the Cardinals at home. Then, with a chance to rebound against a division foe they've had success against, the Giants didn't even show up.

Their season is like Mickey Rourke's acting career: A promising start that was followed by disaster after disaster.

Do the Giants have the equivalent of The Wrestler left in them?

Maybe they should call Rourke. Their defense needs a facelift, and isn't he an expert on that?

After the Saints blew out the Giants, the one thing Saints sources said was that they knew they could throw it on the Giants secondary. If they blocked the pass rush, they would beat the Giants.

They did, and they did. And so have the past two teams, including the Eagles this week. The Giants secondary has been torched and that has put a lot of extra pressure on an offense that isn't playing well.

Eli Manning's past three games haven't been good. He has thrown three touchdown passes and six interceptions, including two Sunday as the Giants fell to 5-3.

For their efforts, or lack of, the Giants get an F here in our CBSSports.com Week 8 Grades. The Giants are now third in their division, a half game behind the Eagles and Dallas Cowboys, both at 5-2.

Three weeks. Three games. How quickly it can all change.

Think I can dump five pounds in the next 21 days? Nah, it's fat-ball season.

 
Sunday, Nov. 1, 2009
Philadelphia Eagles 40, NY Giants 17Prev. GradeGPA
A
Eagles: Donovan McNabb lit up the Giants, which wasn't tough to do. The Eagles also ran the ball well, with Leonard Weaver's long run setting the tone. The defense did the rest, with two interceptions.
B
2.94
F
Giants: The pass defense continues to be a major problem. It was exposed in New Orleans and the two games since. Eli Manning had another tough time, his interception in the first quarter helping Philly to a 14-0 lead.
C-
2.59
Miami Dolphins 30, NY Jets 25Prev. GradeGPA
B
Dolphins: They won this game with returns. Ted Ginn Jr. had two of them on kickoff returns and Jason Taylor had a fumble return for a score. That helped offset a lack of offense. But they found a way.
C+
2.23
C-
Jets: They let a good defensive effort go to waste with poor special-teams play. That hurts. The offense moved the ball, but the turnover for a touchdown was a killer. Rex Ryan went for two too early and it cost them.
A
2.67
Indianapolis Colts 18, San Francisco 49ers 14Prev. GradeGPA
C
Colts: Peyton Manning had another big day, but they couldn't score touchdowns. He threw for 347 yards and Reggie Wayne had 12 catches for 147 yards and a score. That should mean more points. The defense gave up one big play to Frank Gore, but played OK the rest of the way. Still, pretty lackluster.
B+
3.09
C-
49ers: They played tough, but they didn't do enough on offense. Gore had one big play, but that's it. The defense bent, but stiffened when it needed to. They played feisty for a team that was playing a second consecutive road game.
C
2.39
St. Louis Rams 17, Detroit Lions 10Prev. GradeGPA
B
Rams: Give this one to Steven Jackson. He ran for 149 yards and the game-winning touchdown to break the losing streak. The defense, which has been maligned for most of the season, played well.
F
1.56
C
Lions: They didn't do enough on offense and the defense couldn't stop Jackson. Matt Stafford wasn't great in his first game back after missing a couple with a knee injury.
D
1.91
Dallas Cowboys 38, Seattle Seahawks 17Prev. GradeGPA
A
Cowboys: Tony Romo killed the Seahawks with three touchdown passes, his third consecutive big game. The defense did the rest. Patrick Crayton's punt return in the third quarter sealed it.
A
3.06
D
Seahawks: They couldn't get anything going on offense and their pass defense continued to be a major problem. This isn't a very good team right now -- even with Matt Hasselbeck.
F
1.86
Chicago Bears 30, Cleveland Browns 6Prev. GradeGPA
B
Bears: The defense had an easy day against a bad offense. That unit forced five turnovers, which was the big difference in the game. The Bears offense was OK, but not great. It didn't have to be.
F
2.29
F
Browns: The offense gets worse by the week. Derek Anderson was terrible and they turned it over all day long. The defense has no chance with the offense playing like that.
F
0.93
Houston Texans 31, Buffalo Bills 10Prev. GradeGPA
B
Texans: Ryan Moats had a big day running it. Matt Schaub, save for two interceptions, was good and the defense handled the Buffalo offense all day long. They never let Buffalo get it going.
B
2.50
F
Bills: Ryan Fitzpatrick isn't very good. You can't win with the way he played Sunday. The defense was gashed by the run all day long. They can't stop anybody. This wasn't what we expected in this spot after two road victories.
B-
1.84
Baltimore Ravens 30, Denver Broncos 7Prev. GradeGPA
A
Ravens: The big play was the kickoff return for a touchdown to open the second half. The defense did the rest. They rendered Kyle Orton and that passing game useless. The Broncos had trouble getting anything going on offense.
C+
2.90
C-
Broncos: They didn't do anything on offense. They were bad on third down, and didn't throw anything down the field. The defense bent in the second half, but was on the field a lot. This was a tough spot for the Broncos against a team that had to have it.
A
3.43
Tennessee Titans 30, Jacksonville Jaguars 13Prev. GradeGPA
B+
Titans: Forget Vince Young. Any quarterback can win with Chris Johnson running wild the way he did. What a day with 228 yards and two touchdowns. The defense played much better, aside from two big runs by Maurice Jones-Drew.
F
1.63
F
Jaguars: Jones-Drew was the only player who showed up. They weren't good passing it and the defense was terrible. They acted like they never tackled before.
B-
1.87
San Diego Chargers 24, Oakland Raiders 16Prev. GradeGPA
B
Chargers: The defense was all over JaMarcus Russell, which was the difference in the game. San Diego had five sacks, two by Shawne Merriman, his first two of the season. Philip Rivers was sharp again.
A
2.47
D
Raiders: One day that passing game will work. When? Who knows. But JaMarcus Russell isn't there yet. The offensive line doesn't help him either.
F
1.00
Carolina Panthers 34, Arizona Cardinals 21Prev. GradeGPA
A+
Panthers: They ran well again with DeAngelo Williams and Jonathan Stewart. But the reason they won was the defense. That unit forced six Kurt Warner turnovers, one of those a touchdown off an interception return by Julius Peppers.
F
1.77
F
Cardinals: That was another home disaster. This team is tough to figure out. Warner was bad again, with five picks. He also lost a fumble. And what happened to that defense that had been playing so well?
B+
2.24
Minnesota Vikings 38, Green Bay Packers 26Prev. GradeGPA
B
Vikings: Brett Favre threw four touchdown passes to rub it in the faces of the Packers. The concern is the defense let down in the second half. The pass defense went to sleep with a big lead.
C
2.96
C-
Packers: They fell behind and then didn't have enough to come back. Aaron Rodgers tried, but the defense couldn't stop the Vikings when it needed to. The offensive line had issues again.
A
2.80
Monday, Nov. 2, 2009
New Orleans Saints 35, Atlanta Falcons 27Prev. GradeGPA
B
Saints: They played a heck of a first half, but didn't do much in the second. The offense went to sleep, except for one drive. The four turnovers, one for a score, were tough to take. This wasn't great, but they found a way.
B-
3.47
B-
Falcons: They had their chances to steal this one, but couldn't come up with the big plays in the end. Michael Turner ran well, but Matt Ryan's three interceptions really hurt, especially the one with a chance to go up 31-28. The defense did play better against that Saints offense in the second half.
C-
2.73
 
Talk Back
Reputation:92
Level:All-Star
Since:Jan 24, 2007

January 25, 2010 4:55 pm
As stated last week,NEVER mention Rivers in the same sentence as Peyton Manning unless you say Rivers sucks. Manning carved up the Jets defense for 377 yards and 3 TD and NO INT-the same defense that Rivers could NOT solve and threw the pic that gave the Jets the lead. Manning did not leave it to the kicker to win he game like that loser Rivers did. Rivers not capable of leading a team to anything ...(more)
Reputation:97
Level:Superstar
Since:Apr 29, 2007

December 28, 2009 12:17 pm
What a waste of all that jack Manning is. I bet the Giants would like a redo and keep Rivers instead of getting Manning. I know, Manning has won a Superbowl, and Burress is not there but Manning is just not consistent enough. Rivers is looking far more consistant right now. No way Manning should be the highest paid player in the NFL!!!
Reputation:98
Level:Superstar
Since:Dec 19, 2007

January 19, 2010 12:39 pm

The game was over when Norv decided to lay it down in the 2<sup> nd</sup> quarter, running up the middle on 3<sup> rd</sup> and 5 (when our avg run was like 2 yards) with 2:30 minutes left and then punting the ball was a stupid move, to me that series changed the whole game. Why not put the ball in the Rivers hands and maybe go into half time with a possible 10- 14 p ...(more)

Reputation:94
Level:All-Star
Since:Jun 7, 2008

January 19, 2010 1:49 am
Is Prisco the only one saying over and over and over again that the NFL is "all about passing." Look, the passing is game is great and fun to watch but I don't think it is the Superbowl formula. Sure the Saints, Vikings, and Colts have great quarterbacks and can put up points, but the Superbowl is about whose defense is better. The last two years proves my point with the Steelers and Gia ...(more)
Reputation:90
Level:All-Star
Since:Oct 1, 2009

January 11, 2010 9:05 pm
I think it is quite apparent at this point that Brady is a great statue quarterback.  But unfortunately for Tom, in the NFL today it is necessary for the leader of the team to be able to have at least minimal mobility.  I saw some of his completions against the Ravens and he literally had the day.  However; whenever pressured, he made very poor decisions and threw the ball into cove ...(more)
Reputation:94
Level:All-Star
Since:Sep 23, 2006

January 11, 2010 4:45 pm
Quote from Vikes Steelers game---

"Facts are facts. Favre gagged in the fourth quarter Sunday, and now the Vikings aren't undefeated anymore. He threw for 334 yards, but two fourth-quarter turnovers for scores were what lost this game.

Free pass? Not here.

On the first turnover, Favre held the ball too long and Steelers defensive end ...(more)

Reputation:93
Level:All-Star
Since:Dec 18, 2006

November 9, 2009 4:53 pm
Seriously, did you want them to go for it on 4th and 11 from the Dallas 32?  Were you watching the game?  The Eagles O-line was not going to hold up on an obvious passing down like that.  At least with the field goal, the Eagles got to kick the ball, and if the D mans up and stops somebody then they get the ball back with 2 minutes left with a chance to run the 2 min offense.  ...(more)
Reputation:97
Level:Superstar
Since:May 24, 2008

January 4, 2010 5:10 pm
I am not sure how to look at this playoff picture for the Ravens. They have shown life in many games this season like the dropped pass in NE, missed FG against Minn, or the close game against Pitt and Indy. I think if they wake up they could be a huge threat. What does everyone else think??
Reputation:95
Level:Superstar
Since:Jul 7, 2007

January 19, 2010 2:40 pm
Typical response form certain type of sports reportere. Prisco incures this double standard of Sean Paton not being thick skinned about opinions fron the media to the fact that they're rusty down the stretch, yet obviously Payton's one little tongue in cheek comment obviously upset Prisco enough where he has to dedicate his entire lead in to it, instead instad of focusing on the Saints p ...(more)
Reputation:99
Level:Superstar
Since:Aug 17, 2006

January 18, 2010 4:34 pm
    Really Prisco?  So after your month-long lovefest with the Cowboys, you're not even going to bring up how wrong you were?  You're just going to move on to hopping on the Saints bandwagon?

   Look, I hope the Saints win this weekend, very badly in fact.  But Prisco has been loving the Cowboys and hating Favre all year long.  He has writt
...(more)
Reputation:98
Level:Superstar
Since:Apr 18, 2007

January 19, 2010 2:18 pm
Come on man, pick the Vikings to win...  Most of the teams you pick to win, lose!   I want the Saints to win it all so that Drew Brees won't have any trouble getting to the Hall of Fame.  You sportswriters seem to think that a team accomplishment is needed to get an individual into the HOF.
Reputation:94
Level:All-Star
Since:Sep 7, 2007

January 19, 2010 11:48 am
Pete - you successfully picked 1 game out of 4 - your grade is 25% and we're going to have to hold you back for another year... your mom will need to sign the report card and send it back.

The Saints receive an "A+" for their "stout" defense which gave up an average of 410 yds in previous 5 reg season games. First play of game for Cardinals was a 79-yd TD run&nb
...(more)
Reputation:97
Level:Superstar
Since:Jan 20, 2007

January 18, 2010 2:09 pm
I don't know if Prisco is grading on curves here or not, but I have a hard time figuring out how he grades like he does.  I am just glad he never was a real teacher, otherwise students would be developing some serious complexes. 

Can anyone explain to me why the Ravens and the Cowboys don't get an F?

I know it really doesn't matter since the games are over, and
...(more)
Reputation:92
Level:All-Star
Since:Jan 24, 2007

January 18, 2010 1:20 pm
Once again Rivers proved he cannot carry a team and cannot win when the chips are on the table. He cannot carry Peyton's jock. The trade by the Giants for Eli has proved to be correct. Idiot Prisco said that San Diego would get the better of Rivers-Eli Manning trade. WRONG! How many rings does Rivers have? NONE! All Charger fans want Brees back. Rivers is a loud mouth,arrogant jerk that will NEVER ...(more)
Reputation:97
Level:Superstar
Since:Oct 27, 2006

January 19, 2010 1:42 pm
Prissy...what's up with your grading of the Saints and the Vikings?  You give the Saints an A+, but only an A to the Vikings.  Why?

Weren't you writing the past 2 weeks about how great the Cowboys are and they are the best team in the NFC?  And their defense had finally got to the point of being the best and being able to shut down any offense.  Where was that defens
...(more)
 
 
 
 
CBS Sports Store
Reebok New Orleans Saints Super Bowl XLIV Champions Locker Room T-Shirt
New Orleans Saints XLIV Super Bowl Champs
Get your Gear Shop Now