| Forgot Log-in ID / Password? | Help | Not a member, Register Now! |
| Blog Home |
My take on the Meachem controversyI wanted an opportunity to weigh in on the Robert Meachem issue without dedicating any more column space to it.
Frankly, whether or not it's the right call is a moot point to me. The ruling had to go one way or another and would affect different people differently no matter which way it went. We could argue which way is "more right" without coming to any real consensus, so in the end, it's nothing more than a waste of energy. What I don't understand is why so many people blew a fuse over the call, knowing a ruling had to be made, knowing that ruling could go either way and knowing it was made without any sort of bias. If your commissioner chose not to credit the touchdown to Meachem and happened to be playing the guy who started Meachem -- a game he won by five points -- I could understand the controversy. But nothing like that happened here. Nobody likes to lose, sure, but that goes for the people helped by this ruling as well as the ones hurt by it. So even if in all your complaining, with your "heightened logic" and "airtight reasoning," you did get the call reversed, what exactly would you have accomplished? You'd have an opponent with just as much of a right to complain as you do, with a burning rage just as fierce as yours -- perhaps even more fierce since he originally had the call go his way. And would that be a fulfilling victory? Would it give any sort of indication of your Fantasy Football prowess? Which brings me to my next point: What exactly did this decision deny you? A deserved victory? Really? Fantasy Football is about making accurate predictions, and when the lineup deadline came Sunday morning, nobody on the face on planet said, "Heck yeah, I'll start Meachem. I don't want to miss out on those six points he'll get when he strips the ball from a defensive back and returns it for a touchdown." Not a one. In fact, I'd argue nobody -- at least nobody reasonable -- expected him to have 142 receiving yards and a touchdown, in which case anyone who started him already got lucky with him. Another six points added to Meachem's total is not at all reflective of your assessment on him going into the game, so if you need those points to win, you quite frankly don't deserve to win. And that's the most consolation I can offer you. If you play Fantasy long enough, you'll have more moments like this where a questionable call doesn't go your way. The best way I've found to handle them is to remind myself that if I had made better decisions or if my other players had performed the way they should have, I wouldn't have needed those extra six points. That line of thinking helps put the supposed "injustice" in perspective. Because as a willing participant in any game, be it Fantasy Football, horseshoes or Monopoly, you kind of just have accept the rules as they are, assuming they're fair, regardless of whether or not you agree with them. Hey, if you want all the calls to go your way, you could always run a one-team league.
Category: NFL
Tags: Fantasy Football
Early mock draft resultsI recently took part in a mock draft for another publication. Kind of early, I know, but at least it gives you some idea what to expect. It's a 15-team league, so don't take the specific rounds too much to heart (unless you play in a 15-team league, of course).
Here's the breakdown, with the rounds in parentheses. I picked eighth overall: C - Joe Mauer (1) C - Jesus Flores (20) 1B - Derrek Lee (7) 2B - Ben Zobrist (4) 3B - Pablo Sandoval (3) SS - Troy Tulowitzki (2) MI - Alcides Escobar (18) CI - Garrett Jones (11) OF - Shane Victorino (5) OF - Michael Bourn (6) OF - Nick Swisher (14) OF - Seth Smith (22) OF - Will Venable (23) DH - Hideki Matsui (16) SP - Tommy Hanson (8) SP - Gavin Floyd (12) SP - John Danks (13) SP - Daisuke Matsuzaka (15) SP - Wade Davis (19) SP - Joel Pineiro (21) RP - Brian Fuentes (9) RP - David Aardsma (10) RP - Kerry Wood (17) For the most part, I like what I did. According to the tier approach -- where with each pick, I target the position most likely to see the biggest drop-off in talent before my next pick -- Joe Mauer in the first round and Troy Tulowitzki in the second seems like the ideal way to start a draft this year. That doesn't mean I'd take Mauer before Albert Pujols or even Hanley Ramirez, but if you pick third or later and have the good fortune of drafting Mauer, you should hold your breath and pray Tulowitzki slides to you in Round 2. That's the only realistic way you can come out of the draft with top-tier players at the two weakest positions in Fantasy. You can still get top-tier players at the deeper positions in the rounds that follow. Going with Mauer and Tulowitzki does have its drawbacks, though. I don't have a sure 30 homers anywhere, and if Derrek Lee (who should go sooner than Round 7 even in 12-team leagues) regresses back to his usual numbers, I might fall behind in that category. Fortunately, drafting Mauer and Pablo Sandoval gave me the luxury of drafting power hitters who might drain my batting average, such as Garrett Jones and Nick Swisher. Michael Bourn should help me contend in stolen bases, though if I knew I'd end up with him and Alcides Escobar, I would have opted for Andre Ethier's homers instead of Shane Victorino's steals in Round 5. I waited until the eighth round to draft a pitcher and still ended up with a competitive staff, which is always the plan. Daisuke Matsuzaka and Wade Davis have some potential for implosion, but I like their upside. I normally avoid non-strikeout pitchers like Joel Pineiro, but rarely do 15-game winners last so long in leagues so deep. What do you guys think? I'm still forming my opinions at this early stage of the offseason, so any dissenting viewpoints can only help. Send an e-mail with the heading "15-team draft" to DMFantasyBaseball@cbs.com.
Category: MLB
Tags: Fantasy Baseball, mock drafts
Davies and a couple comebacksA pair of pitching performances caught my eye Thursday. How long before he replaces David Murphy in the lineup?
Category: MLB
Tags: Fantasy Baseball
Quick predictionsI unfortunately won't get a chance to go into much detail, but I wanted to get my predictions on record so people can ridicule them and me and whatever else they want.
Category: MLB
Tags: Fantasy Baseball
Street earns job; Rasmus closing inWith most of the roster spots filled and starting pitchers making their final tuneup starts before the regular season, Thursday was a relatively quiet day in baseball.
Category: MLB
Tags: Fantasy Baseball
Late spring surprisesI missed a couple days of blogging, so forgive me if I touch on some outdated events.
Category: MLB
Tags: Fantasy Baseball
Closer news is bad newsI checked out the Mets at the Orioles on Sunday, which might have given me more to discuss if a rain delay in the first inning hadn't forced both starting pitchers out of the game.
Category: MLB
Tags: Fantasy Baseball
Not high on HeadleyI've devoted so much of this blog to the players I like that I sometimes neglect the ones I don't.
Category: MLB
Tags: Fantasy Baseball
Concerns regarding some sleeper pitchersI got a chance to see the Marlins face the Orioles on Thursday and to confirm some of my suspicions on Anibal Sanchez.
Category: MLB
Tags: Fantasy Baseball
Price down; Salty and Johnson upWell, that's that.
Category: MLB
Tags: Fantasy Baseball
The good keep getting betterSince I have only so much time to devote to this blog every day, I refuse to write about the same players over and over again.
Category: MLB
Tags: Fantasy Baseball
Cubs staff and love for LowrieI can't talk about Thursday's baseball action without mentioning Cubs manager Lou Piniella's inevitable decision to make Sean Marshall his fifth starter. He earned it, compiling a 0.63 ERA in 14 1/3 innings this spring. Actually, he earned it years ago, but the Cubs never had a sufficient opening in their rotation. I have my doubts he can strike out at least seven batters per nine innings, which might cause me to shy away from him in mixed leagues, but in NL-only leagues, he's a no-brainer after the usual names go off the board.
Category: MLB
Tags: Fantasy Baseball
Tommy John survivors thrivingChris Carpenter just keeps getting better and better, pitching a full six scoreless innings against the Orioles on Thursday. That's midseason form right there. He now has 14 scoreless innings this spring. The J.D. Salinger of MLB aces needed two full years to recover from reconstructive elbow surgery, but you have to remember that when we last saw him, he finished third in NL Cy Young voting. I'd feel better if he had more than four strikeouts during those 14 innings of work, but if I hold that against him, I'm just looking for flaws. If you can get him after every Zack Greinke and Brett Myers goes of the board, you have a pretty good bargain.
Category: MLB
Tags: Fantasy Baseball
Add Spilborghs to the list of sleepersIt finally happened. Kyle Davies had a bad spring start, allowing five runs in three innings against the Rockies on Tuesday. So much for that 0.71 ERA, but I'm not ready to write him off just yet. Remember, his sleeper potential had more to do with his 4-1 record and 2.27 ERA last September than anything that happened this spring. I still can't convince myself to draft him in a mixed league, though -- or at least I haven't yet. And Todd Helton also homered for the Rockies -- his third in only 14 at-bats, all of them bombs. Just how sore was his back, and for how long? We know it affected his power last year, but we haven't seen this kind of outburst from him since 2004. I don't think it really means anything for someone expected to sit once or twice a week, but Helton at least has my attention. **For those wondering, someone beat me to Jordan Zimmermann in my 10-team mixed-league draft. Oh well. That guy jumped on him sooner than I was willing to do -- Round 19 -- so I can't feel all that disappointed. But the fact someone reached for him before the last round shows just how much buzz he has generated from spring training alone. For the person who asked, I think he could make the same kind of impact Justin Verlander made as a rookie in 2006. I can't guarantee it, obviously, but the potential makes him worth a late-round pick in mixed leagues. He probably won't win 17 games like Verlander did for the Tigers that year, but the other numbers look like a good starting point.
Category: MLB
Tags: Fantasy Baseball
Getting gushy over ZimmermannCount me among the many hopping aboard the Jordan Zimmermann bandwagon (though hopefully not too many if I have any hope of drafting him). The Nationals top prospect, already blowing away the competition this spring, had his best performance yet Monday against the Marlins, recording six strikeouts in four scoreless innings. He has recorded 16 strikeouts and allowed only six hits in 12 1/3 scoreless innings this spring, good enough to make manager Manny Acta come dangerously close to awarding him a rotation spot already:
Category: MLB
Tags: Fantasy Baseball
|
About I White; You Read
I've never had a blog before. I'm from Georgia. (Not that that means anything, but people like to joke, and I like to accommodate, so there you go -- fuel for the fire.) But now that I've joined up with CBSSports.com, they've given me a blog space and told me to use it, assigning me a topic on which to direct my focus: baseball -- or, more specifically, Fantasy Baseball. Enjoy.
Recent Blog Entries
I White; You Read
CBS Sports Blogs
I White; You Read's Tags
Scott White's Favorites
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|